Table 1 Characteristics of studies
Study | Years | Type | Species | Age or weight | TGFdose | Control group | Outcomes | Time/d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ermeldan Enewal | 2019 | β3 | Rabbit | 3–4 years, 1.5–2.0 kg | 80 ng/ml | rDPSCs | ①③④⑤⑥ | 7d |
Liu | 2016 | β3 | Rabbit | 2-3 years, 0.8–1.0 kg | 20 ng/ml | DPSCs | ① | / |
Mai Mai Tiemin Harik1 | 2019 | β3 | Rabbit | 2-3 years, 0.8–1.0 kg | / | DPSCs | ①③⑤ | 7d |
Mai Mai Tiemin Harik2 | 2016 | β3 | Rabbit | / | 20 ng/ml | DPSCs | ① | 7d |
Wang | 2017 | β3 | Rabbit | 4 years, 1–1.2 kg | 80 ng/ml | DPSCs | ②③④ | 4-8W |
Wu | 2015 | β3 | Rabbit | 4-6 years, 0.8–1.2 kg | 250 ng/ul | DPSCs | ②③④ | 6W |
Han | 2017 | β3 | Rabbit | 1–2 years, 0.5–0.8 kg | 80 ng/ml | DPSCs | ①② | 7d |
YILIN WANG | 2016 | β3 | Rabbit | 4 years, 0.4–0.5 kg | / | DPSCs | ① | 7d |
Guzalinur Ababakli | 2016 | β3 | Rabbit | 2 years, 2.5–3.0 kg | 80 ng/ml | DPSCs | ①④⑤⑥ | 2-12W |
Jia | 2017 | β1 | Human | 18-25 years | 6 μg/L | DPSCs | ① | 7d |
Ren | 2014 | β3 | Human | 7–8 years | 25 ng/mL | DPSCs | ①② | 7d |
Xu | 2014 | β1 | Human | / | 5 ng/ml | DPSCs | ① | 7d |
Jiang | 2018 | β1 | Human | / | 20 ng/mL | DPSCs | ②③⑤ | 7d |