Skip to main content

Table 5 Mortality over time and overall survival in untreated children with MLD

From: The natural history and burden of illness of metachromatic leukodystrophy: a systematic literature review

Author(s), year,

country

Late-infantile MLD

Juvenile MLD

OS for late-infantile MLD, years

Survival rates for

late-infantile MLD

OS for juvenile MLD, years

Survival rates for

juvenile MLD

Fumagalli et al. 2021 [49]

Italy

Median OS (time from symptom onset)

• Overall (n = 22): 8.42a

• Ambulant (n = 13): 9.17

• Non-ambulant (n = 9): 8.42 (P = 0.9424 vs. ambulant)

• Median OS (from birth):

• Ambulant (n = 13): 10.17

 • Non-ambulant (n = 9): 9.42 (P = 0.5768 vs. ambulant)

• 5 years from symptom onset: 56%

 • 10 years from symptom onset: 40%

Median OS (time from symptom onset)

• Early-juvenile (n = 14): not reached

 • Early-juvenile subgroup with motor symptoms at onset (n = 9): not reached

• Early-juvenile subgroup with only cognitive symptoms at onset (n = 5): not reached

• Late-juvenile (n = 5): not reached

Early-juvenile (n = 14)

• 5 years: 90%

•10 years: 80%

•15 years: 68.6%

 Early-juvenile subgroup with motor symptoms at onset (n = 9)

•15 years: 68.6%

Early-juvenile subgroup with only cognitive symptoms at onset (n = 5)

• 15 years: 66.7%

Late-juvenile (n = 5)

• 5 years: 100%

• 10 years: 100%

•15 years: 100%

Groeschel et al. 2016 [52]

Germany

N/A

N/A

Untreated

  •Median age at follow-up: 15.8 years (range: 3.9–47.1 years)

Untreated

•  5 years from disease onset:b 100% (41/41)

• 5 years from baseline evaluation:b 73% (30/41)

Liaw et al. 2015 [61]

Taiwan

Of 5 patients in total, 3 patients had follow-up data: 2 died at 7.34 years old and 4.75 years old (both from respiratory failure) and 1 was alive at 8 years of age

NR

N/A

N/A

Mahmood et al. 2010 [63]

USA

NR

5 years from onset of symptoms: 25.1%

10 years from onset of symptoms: 0%c

NR

5 years from onset of symptoms: 70.3%

10 years from onset of symptoms: 44.3%c

Author(s), year,

country

Studies not reporting by subtype of MLD

OS for MLD, years

Survival rates for MLD, years

van Rappard et al. 2016 [101]

Netherlands

8 untreated patients (36%) died 22–72 months after diagnosisd

At latest assessment

Untreated (n = 22): 63.6% at ~ 70 monthse since diagnosisf

  1. No studies were identified reporting mortality data for untreated adult patients with MLD
  2. CI: confidence interval; HR: hazard ratio; MLD: metachromatic leukodystrophy; N/A: not applicable; NR: not reported; OS: overall survival
  3. aThe insertion of a percutaneous gastrostomy tube was not associated with prolonged survival in patients with late-infantile MLD (HR 0.78 [95% CI: 0.33–1.83]; P = 0.572)
  4. bMedian (range) age at disease onset was 6.5 (2.7–16.0) years
  5. cThe systematic review described in Mahmood et al. 2010 excluded studies that were limited to patients receiving transplants
  6. dSubtypes NR; all were < 16 years of age
  7. eApproximate values read from graphs in publication
  8. fSubtypes NR