Novel method for reduction of virus load in blood plasma by sonication
European Journal of Medical Research volume 25, Article number: 12 (2020)
Aim of the present study is the evaluation of ultrasound as a physical method for virus inactivation in human plasma products prior to transfusion. Our study is focused on achieving a high level of virus inactivation simultaneously leaving blood products unaltered, measured by the level of degradation of coagulation factors, especially in third world countries where virus contamination of blood products poses a major problem. Virus inactivation plays an important role, especially in the light of newly discovered or unknown viruses, which cannot be safely excluded via prior testing.
Taking into account the necessary protection of the relevant coagulation activity for plasma, the basis for a sterile virus inactivation under shielding gas insufflation was developed for future practical use. Influence of frequency and power density in the range of soft and hard cavitation on the inactivation of transfusion-relevant model viruses for Hepatitis-(BVDV = bovine diarrhea virus), for Herpes-(SFV = Semliki Forest virus, PRV = pseudorabies virus) and Parvovirus B19 (PPV = porcine parvovirus) were examined. Coagulation activity was examined via standard time parameters to minimize reduction of functionality of coagulation proteins. A fragmentation of coagulation proteins via ultrasound was ruled out via gel electrophoresis. The resulting virus titer was examined using end point titration.
Through CO2 shielding gas insufflation—to avoid radical emergence effects—the coagulation activity was less affected and the time window for virus inactivation substantially widened. In case of the non-lipidated model virus (AdV-luc = luciferase expressing adenoviral vector), the complete destruction of the virus capsid through hard cavitation was proven via scanning electron microscopy (SEM). This can be traced back to microjets and shockwaves occurring in hard cavitation. The degree of inactivation seems to depend on size and compactness of the type of viruses. Using our pre-tested and subsequently chosen process parameters with the exception of the small PPV, all model viruses were successfully inactivated and reduced by up to log 3 factor. For a broad clinical usage, protection of the coagulation activities may require further optimization.
Building upon the information gained, an optimum inactivation can be reached via raising of power density up to 1200 W and simultaneous lowering of frequency down to 27 kHz. In addition, the combination of the two physical methods UV treatment and ultrasound may yield optimum results without the need of substance removal after the procedure.
Since the introduction of blood transfusion security levels of the blood transfer process between individual humans for medical purposes have been a key issue, periodically aggravated by current virus circulations in society. Initially the topic had become a major concern after the discovery of HIV. The current security concept includes careful donor recruiting under elimination of high-risk groups, testing for presence or absence of virus in donor blood and utilization of newly developed measures for virus inactivation.
In Germany, all blood and plasma products are regarded as pharmaceuticals and thus are subject to pharmaceutical legislation. In 1998 in Germany, a new law on blood transfusion was passed and amended in 2007 and 2017 . Human blood is a valuable resource and raw material for vital components such as: erythrocyte concentrate = packed red blood cells, platelet concentrate, fresh (frozen) plasma (FFP). FFP itself poses the raw material for several components of plasma. Plasma derivatives are produced from plasma pools, consisting of plasma of thousands of donors. This method raises the risk of a potential infection in comparison to a singular plasma donation, as a pool can be contaminated by one single infectious donation. This justifies the intense efforts on behalf of the plasma processing industry to find methods for inactivation of at least all known virus types.
Blood and blood component transfusions can cause transfer of parasites, bacteria and viruses resulting in serious infections . Since 1999, examination for transfusion-relevant virus HCV and since 2004 for HIV via nucleic acid amplification test (NAT) have become mandatory. This leaves a minimum residual risk due to limitations in sensitivity and specificity of analysis methods as well as the pooling method of NAT .
Various methods for virus depletion and inactivation are available  as outlined. In addition chemical methods for virus inactivation in plasma from pools and in singular plasma are available . Most of these mechanisms additionally damage proteins and reduce activity of coagulation factors.
The solvent detergent method poses the best known and most common, feasible method for lipidated viruses primarily for use on plasma pools. Methylene blue inactivation is not yet authorized in Germany, but is employed in other EU states. It exerts its inactivation via interaction of methylene blue with the genome of the virus and subsequent radiation with sodium light. This generally works for all viruses, but cannot inactivate some non-lipidated viruses such as, e.g., PPV. Inactivation methods using psoralenes (furocumarine), gene toxic substances, are currently in development , while the Intercept Blood™ system, using Amotosalen is already in use reducing pathogen activity in plasma .
Most of the above described methods require separation of the plasma from the employed chemicals, posing an additional effort and the need for testing of rest substance. Thus, ultrasound as a purely physical method poses a novel, effective and easily usable alternative.
Ultrasound used for sonication describes sound waves at a frequency above approximately 20 kHz, non-audible to humans, generated by electrically triggered quartz resonators and radiated in potent bundle format. The transmittable energy finds a high range of use in industry and military as well as in medical setups, e.g., to detach bacteria in clinical microbiological diagnostics or to detect implant-associated infections . To inactivate all harmful microorganisms, especially viruses, one of the desired effects of ultrasound can be soft and hard cavitation , potentially causing mechanical stress or even damage . Cell damaging effects of ultrasound rely on mechanical destruction of cell walls, change of conformation of proteins and carbohydrates and damage of free DNA through hard cavitation .
The goal of the underlying study is the detailed examination of ultrasound treatment for inactivation of transfusion-associated viruses including proof of virus inactivation by ultrasound, detection of optimal physical parameters such as time, frequency and power of ultrasound treatment and evaluation of ultrasound’s effects on the coagulation activity of plasma proteins. Ultrasound triggers chemical (radical) and mechanical (cavitation) reactions. In presence of oxygen, the radical reactions can destroy proteins, including coagulation factors . Initial goal of the study was to find the ideal time window for least damage on coagulation factors in combination with maximum effect on virus inactivation. In the first part, specific effects of ultrasound under oxygen or shielding gas  on coagulation proteins were tested. The modifications were compared via measurement of partial thromboplastin time according to Quick (PT), activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT), fibrinogen, coagulation factors such as FIX and FVIII to evaluate effects on extrinsic and intrinsic coagulation.
Materials and methods
Influence on coagulation by sonication
Initially, reduction of global tests such as Quick, elongation of aPTT and reduction of factors fibrinogen, FIX and FVIII after 60-min ultrasound treatment in varying frequency were tested and compared. Each test was repeated five times. Ultrasound baths of various sizes and sources for various frequencies from 27 kHz up to 250 kHz were employed, yielding a variation of power density, as described in Table 1.
Virus inactivation was conducted in standardized 150 ml Compoflex® bloodbags, the connecting tube shortened to 1 cm and the interface connected via a 3-way-connector. The bag was then stabilized by a holding frame inside the ultrasound container. For CO2 fumigation the blood bags were inserted into a custom-made pressure chamber.
Ultrasound treatment of standardized and documented virus suspensions in PBS and plasma as outlined in Table 5 was always conducted in the exact same procedure: 50 ml plasma per bag were treated, after the procedure samples were immediately frozen at − 80 °C until analysis. Ultrasound treatment under oxygen was performed at 27 kHz and 42 kHz at a power density of 1.60 W/cm2. Two blood bags were prepared, one as a control group, the other as the treatment test. Times of sampling (5 ml per sampling time) can be seen in Table 2:
For sequential testing of plasma, virus suspension and PBS, three bags were employed as shown in Fig. 1. One bag served as an untreated control group, the other two were saturated for 150 min at 10 bar with carbon dioxide, while one served as the CO2 control group, the other was used for ultrasound sampling.
The positive controls were kept for an equal time period in the water container under the exact same conditions. Acoustic exposure was then conducted for 5 h and samples taken in pre-defined time intervals. High power density tests were sampled every 30 min, low power every 60 min as described in Table 3.
Fresh frozen plasma for the conduction of all tests was obtained from blood donation service Baden-Württemberg. Inactivation testing of virus loaded plasma was conducted at the Paul-Ehrlich-Institute as outlined below. Plasma was thawed at 37 °C, portioned in 50-ml units and processed immediately.
Inactivation of viral test microorganisms
Inactivation of the model viruses was conducted in PBS. Sample viruses employed are listed in Table 4:
To measure maximum CO2 saturation of plasma (for optimum removal of oxygen), partial pressures of CO2, O2, and pH values were tracked using the blood gas measurement system Synthesis 10 (Werfen GmbH, Vienna).
AdV-luc is a replication-deficient Adenovirus of human serotype 5 sized at roughly 90 nm with a double-stranded DNA. The so-called firefly luciferase gene is expressed under the control of the CMV promotor.
Biologic activity of coagulation proteins was conducted via measurement of the global thromboplastin time using the Quick test (PT), as well as the activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT).
Virus count was conducted after staining with trypan blue to differentiate viability of cells. Cell count was conducted via microscope in a Neubauer counting chamber. Cytotoxicity was evaluated using the WST-1 assay.
Samples sonicated at 27 kHz under shielding gas protection were used for electrophoretic examination. Initially, the positive control samples (−CO2, −US and +CO2, +US) at the beginning (0 h) and end of sonication (5 h) were applied, followed by samples of plasma after 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 h, separated in 8–16% Tris-Glycine-Gradient Gel at a voltage of 125 V and output of 57 mA. The recombined SDS-Page-Protein-Marker was used as a mass standard in the range of 10–150 kDa. Prior to electrophoretic analysis of the plasma samples, the albumin fraction was reduced, using an albumin removal kit by diluting 60 µl of plasma with 540 µl of binding buffer.
The extraction column was put onto a solid phase chamber, equilibrated with 1 ml of binding buffer and the diluted sample applied to the column. Further elution was conducted via gravity and the sample collected in a sample jar. The column was then flushed twice using 600 ml binding buffer. The collected extracts contained the albumin reduced sample.
For electrophoresis the sample was then in a ratio of 1:1 diluted with an extraction buffer. Additionally, one drop of Bromphenol blue was added to control the electrophoretic characteristics and one drop of sugar solution to load the sample. 6 µl of each sample were applied to the gel.
The virus titer was measured employing standard endpoint titration in eight replication cycles. The virus containing solution was diluted until no cytotoxic effect was measurable. Virus was sowed, diluted, titrated and in the end the tissue culture infective dose, TCID50/ml was measured. The plates were examined regarding cytopathic effects caused by virus infections. Calculation was conducted in computer support based on probit analysis.
During data evaluation mean values and standard deviations were calculated from at least five replicates. Calculation of mean values from several measurements was accompanied by the Gaussian error propagation law. The Student’s t test was conducted to get information about significances at a p-level of 0.05 by using Microsoft Excel 2016.
Influence on coagulation by sonication
Virus inactivation in blood plasma can only be regarded successful if simultaneously proteins for coagulation remain more or less intact by choosing an optimum time window and energy level. Influence of sonication treatments at 27 and 42 kHz for 60 min on coagulation parameters (n = 5) are shown in Table 5:
Preliminary literature and testing showed the protective function of CO2 insufflation prior to the ultrasound treatment. Displacement results of O2 by CO2 as a shielding gas by inserting carbon dioxide at 0.5 bar pressure can be seen in Fig. 2.
The used plasma samples showed an initial partial pressure of CO2 of 48 mmHg and pO2 of 151 mmHg. Introduction of CO2 led to a steep rise in pCO2 an equivalent linear decrease in pH from 7.3 to 6.3. In contrast, pO2 decreased relatively slowly.
Testing the activity of plasma coagulation factors after CO2 gas insufflation showed a marginal influence on overall clotting tests such as thromboplastin time and aPTT. On the other hand, activity of FVIII decreased by 10% and FIX by 18% on average.
Examination of the influence of ultrasound treatment on Quick, on aPTT, or coagulation factors such as fibrinogen, Factor IX and Factor VIII in summary showed the following: Extensive length of acoustic exposure yielded a reduction of coagulation activity in plasma, strongest influence displayed at low frequencies with high power density. Strongest influence was shown at 250 kHz on factor VIII activity, yielding a reduction of 68% (180 min) and 75% (300 min). Lowest influence was proven for a frequency of 70 kHz as shown in Table 6.
Pre-testing for side effects has thus proven the frequency of 250 kHz to be unsuitable. For subsequent testing purposes both lipidated and non-lipidated viruses were examined. The observed viruses differ in size, structure of particles as well as structure of nucleic acid and cover the entire range of transfusion-associated viruses regarding characteristics as RNA-virus, DNA-virus, lipidated and non-lipidated viruses.
Influence on coagulation under CO2-shielding gas
See Table 7.
Inactivation of viral test microorganisms
See Tables 8.
Rising quantity of blood transfusions as well as a variety of infectious sources requires modern affordable and reliable methods for inactivation of viruses in blood while simultaneously protecting blood coagulation factors from negative influences. Success and failure of virus inactivation is measured in terms of multiple logarithmic reduction of virus titers. Influence of ultrasound on virus inactivation has been tested and described in literature yielding varying rates of success  partially describing the necessity for additional physical methods . Other methodologies such as temperature changes as previously tested may prove generally efficient in virus inactivation, however, unsuitable for use on plasma products [16, 17].
Previous authors have tested similar methodologies, including pasteurization with regard to its effectiveness on virus inactivation and similar to our research proven the necessity of additional protective measures . Others have tested the effectiveness of light waves on virus inactivation, but so far not yet with regard to human plasma products . Photodynamic radiation has been tested as a method of virus inactivation, however frequently involving the risk of hard-to-control side effects such as undesired destruction or mutation of radiated material . Inactivation of influenza A viruses (IAVs) via sterilization equipment with light-emitting diodes (LEDs) at peak wavelengths of 365 nm (UVA-LED), 310 nm (UVB-LED), and 280 nm (UVC-LED) was tested. These tests proved a decreased accumulation of intracellular total viral RNA in infected Madin–Darby canine kidney cells as well as a suppressed accumulation of intracellular mRNA (messenger RNA), vRNA (viral RNA), and cRNA (complementary RNA), as measured by strand-specific RT-PCR . UVA light’s side effects on blood coagulation has undergone substantial testing in rabbit ear bleeding time. Tests showed that bleeding time influence of radiated human platelets is highly dependent on UVA dose indicating that virucidal AMT/1× UVA treatment does not influence platelet hemostatic function . Furthermore, non-ionic surfactants such as Triton X-100 in combination with heat inactivation at 60 °C for 1 h have been tested in varying concentrations, however so far yielding sufficient effectiveness only for the herpes simplex virus, awaiting further results .
The method examined in our test series has proven to be effective in virus inactivation yet protective for blood’s hemostatic properties. The examined mechanical method yields satisfying results with regard to virus inactivation through hard cavitation as described earlier . The effectiveness of the mechanical method as shown on the model viruses may be caused by a combination of various reasons, based on two hypotheses: Hypothesis one assumes that ultrasound destroys the lipid cover of the viruses or the capsid as proclaimed 75 years ago by Goldman and Lepeschkin . Cavitational effects are assumed to mechanically fracture cells, as proven electron microscopically . Hypothesis two assumes ultrasound to destroy the virus genome by mechanically breaking up sugar–phosphate bridges within the DNA via cavitation as well as destruction of hydrogen bridges via radical reactions [24, 27].
Other authors describe interaction of free radical species development during sonolysis . Hard versus soft cavitational effects as described above were examined and their effectiveness studied . Ultrasound treatment under protection of shielding gas seems to offer an appropriate method for microbiologic treatment of blood products as it is both affordable, safe and can be employed leaving the relevant blood components such as coagulation proteins unimpaired. The lack of addition or subsequent removal of chemical substances renders the procedure both safe and suitable for less developed countries.
Limitations of this study include the small selection of comparable virus stems compared. Yet these virus stems were chosen diligently to allow for a high degree of comparability. The examined method is both time and labor intensive as well as only functional for small amounts of treated blood cells. Consequently, the technology is hardly scalable for industry in developed regions. However, the described method allows a significant increase in safety of blood transfusions in technically less developed regions.
It was clearly shown that ultrasound treatment yields positive results with regard to virus inactivation with minor side effects on coagulation proteins and no signs for cytotoxicity. In addition, hard and soft cavitation effects were compared which clearly showed that influences on virus inactivation and on coagulation factors occurred in different energy ranges. This allows for optimization of mechanical effects. In addition, the new method could potentially be combined with existing physical and chemical methods such as methylene blue or UV radiation.
Further studies may examine the effectiveness on a larger scale, industrialized model. In addition, cost and time consumption could be evaluated to understand the economic effects caused by this new technology.
Availability of data and materials
All relevant data are included in the manuscript. Further detailed data are available upon request.
Bundestag D. Gesetz zur Regelung des Transfusionswesens (Transfusionsgesetz). In: Deutschland B, editor. BGBl I S 1752. Berlin: Springer; 1998.
Fry DE. Occupational blood-borne diseases in surgery. Am J Surg. 2005;190:249–54.
Satake M. Infectious risks associated with the transfusion of blood components and pathogen inactivation in Japan. Int J Hematol. 2004;80:306–10.
Burnouf T, Radosevich M. Nanofiltration of plasma-derived biopharmaceutical products. Haemophilia. 2003;9:24–37.
Niemann F: Aktuelle Sicherheitsaspekte bei Plasmaderivaten. Deutsches Ärzteforum; 2003.
Cassier C, Moustacchi E. Mutagenesis induced by mono- and bi-functional alkylating agents in yeast mutants sensitive to photo-addition of furocoumarins (pso). Mutat Res. 1981;84:37–47.
Irsch J, Seghatchian J. Update on pathogen inactivation treatment of plasma, with the INTERCEPT Blood System: current position on methodological, clinical and regulatory aspects. Transfus Apher Sci. 2015;52:240–4.
Renz N, Feihl S, Cabric S, Trampuz A. Performance of automated multiplex PCR using sonication fluid for diagnosis of periprosthetic joint infection: a prospective cohort. Infection. 2017;45:877–84.
Brennen CE. Cavitation in medicine. Interface Focus. 2015;5:20150022.
Mancia L, Vlaisavljevich E, Xu Z, Johnsen E. Predicting tissue susceptibility to mechanical cavitation damage in therapeutic ultrasound. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2017;43:1421–40.
Kasoji SK, Pattenden SG, Malc EP, Jayakody CN, Tsuruta JK, Mieczkowski PA, Janzen WP, Dayton PA. Cavitation enhancing nanodroplets mediate efficient DNA fragmentation in a bench top ultrasonic water bath. PLoS ONE. 2015;10:e0133014.
Zhao LY, Liu S, Chen ZG, Zou JZ, Wu F. Cavitation enhances coagulated size during pulsed high-intensity focussed ultrasound ablation in an isolated liver perfusion system. Int J Hyper. 2016;2016:1–11.
Jablonowski H, Hansch MA, Dunnbier M, Wende K, Hammer MU, Weltmann KD, Reuter S, Woedtke T. Plasma jet’s shielding gas impact on bacterial inactivation. Biointerphases. 2015;10:029506.
Su X, Zivanovic S, D’Souza DH. Inactivation of human enteric virus surrogates by high-intensity ultrasound. Foodborne Pathog Dis. 2010;7:1055–61.
Burleson GR, Murray TM, Pollard M. Inactivation of viruses and bacteria by ozone, with and without sonication. Appl Microbiol. 1975;29:340–4.
Brie A, Boudaud N, Mssihid A, Loutreul J, Bertrand I, Gantzer C. Inactivation of murine norovirus and hepatitis A virus on fresh raspberries by gaseous ozone treatment. Food Microbiol. 2018;70:1–6.
Estes MK, Graham DY, Smith EM, Gerba CP. Rotavirus stability and inactivation. J Gener Virol. 1979;43:403–9.
Groner A, Broumis C, Fang R, Nowak T, Popp B, Schafer W, Roth NJ. Effective inactivation of a wide range of viruses by pasteurization. Transfusion. 2017;58(1):41–51.
Kingsley D, Perez-Perez RE, Boyd G, Sites J, Niemira BA. Evaluation of 405 nm monochromatic light for inactivation of Tulane virus on blueberry surfaces. J Appl Microbiol. 2017;124(4):1017–22.
Majiya H, Adeyemi OO, Herod M, Stonehouse NJ, Millner P. Photodynamic inactivation of non-enveloped RNA viruses. J Photochem Photobiol B. 2018;189:87–94.
Nishisaka-Nonaka R, Mawatari K, Yamamoto T, Kojima M, Shimohata T, Uebanso T, Nakahashi M, Emoto T, Akutagawa M, Kinouchi Y, Wada T, Okamoto M, Ito H, Yoshida KI, Daidoji T, Nakaya T, Takahashi A. Irradiation by ultraviolet light-emitting diodes inactivates influenza a viruses by inhibiting replication and transcription of viral RNA in host cells. J Photochem Photobiol B. 2018;189:193–200.
Wagner SJ, Bardossy L, Moroff G, Dodd RY, Blajchman MA. Assessment of the hemostatic effectiveness of human platelets treated with aminomethyltrimethyl psoralen and UV A light using a rabbit ear bleeding time technique. Blood. 1993;82:3489–92.
Remy MM, Alfter M, Chiem MN, Barbani MT, Engler OB, Suter-Riniker F. Effective chemical virus inactivation of patient serum compatible with accurate serodiagnosis of infections. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2018;25(7):907.
Kosel J, Gutierrez-Aguirre I, Racki N, Dreo T, Ravnikar M, Dular M. Efficient inactivation of MS-2 virus in water by hydrodynamic cavitation. Water Res. 2017;124:465–71.
Lepeschkin WW, Goldman DE. Effects of ultrasound on cell structure. J Cell Comp Physiol. 1952;40:383–97.
Kinsloe H, Ackerman E, Reid JJ. Exposure of microorganisms to measured sound fields. J Bacteriol. 1954;68:373–80.
Hughes DE, Nyborg WL. Cell disruption by ultrasound. Science. 1962;138:108–14.
Cui H, Zhu Q, Gao Y, Xia H, Tan K, He Y, Liu Z, Xu Y. Ultrasound mediated microbubbles destruction augmented sonolysis: an in vitro and in vivo study. Biomed Res Int. 2017;2017:7021929.
We would like to thank Mrs. Kümpel for her graphic and illustration support.
This work was supported by the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the Technical University of Munich (TUM) in the framework of the Open Access Publishing Program.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
No ethics approval was necessary as no treatment on patients or animals was conducted.
Consent for publication
All authors declare their consent for publication.
None of the authors declare any conflict of interest.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Pförringer, D., Braun, K.F., Mühlhofer, H. et al. Novel method for reduction of virus load in blood plasma by sonication. Eur J Med Res 25, 12 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40001-020-00410-9